Fire Island News & Great South Bay News Headlines Archive for April 11, 2026

In the heart of Bay Shore’s downtown, a quirky 1970s-era time machine has quietly earned a reputation as one of the town’s favorite dive bars. Hidden in plain sight next to the Boulton Center at 27 W Main Street, The Cortland is a place locals know well; stepping inside feels like entering another era. Vibrant disco lights, wood-paneled walls, and a devoted crowd give the late-night spot its own personality. In 2019, owner Bobby G. completely remodeled the space into its current ‘70s theme, which soon became loved by patrons. When the charming spot closed its doors this past December, two Bay Shore residents felt they had to do something about it.

The Cortland’s New Groove: A Favorite Bay Shore Bar Re-Opens

Posted on April 11, 2026

More from our sister sites

Bill O'Reilly

Long Island Press

Bill O’Reilly column: God only knows

Kelli O'Hara, Mark Consuelos and Rose Byrne in "Fallen Angel" on Broadway.

Review | ‘Fallen Angels’ with Kelli O’Hara and Rose Byrne sparkles briefly, then fizzles

A-Lister Podcast_Michael Dowling_sc_VL_Web Banner

Schneps Podcasts

Michael Dowling, CEO emeritus, Northwell Health

Gotham Cheer performs during Brooklyn Pride's 2024 twilight march.

30 years of Brooklyn Pride: How the borough’s twilight march became a Fifth Avenue tradition