Catching Up in Ocean Bay Park

OBP Spaghetti Supper
Anthony Lumagui serves at the Annual Chief Michael Horton Spaghetti Dinner.
Photo by Rachelle King.

Welcome back to Ocean Bay Park my friends! Im excited — and honored — to step into Barbara Gaby Placillas shoes and take over this beloved Ocean Bay Park column. And, thankfully, she doesnt wear heels!

Ocean Bay Park concluded its last season with the much-anticipated annual Halloween Party, which drew a record-breaking 211 participants. The costumes were fantastic across the board, with some clear favorites; but everyone brought their A-game and it was a night to remember.

While many of us think of Memorial Day as the official start of the season on Fire Island, the truly dedicated know it begins with the Polar Bear Plunge on New Years Day. Marking the fifth year, 27 chill seekers took the plunge this year, including many first-timers thrilled to cross it off their bucket list. Afterward, Don and Joanne Madeo hosted the brave swimmers at their home, serving them champagne by the fire. Guests wore matching polar bear onesies or swimsuits in the hot tub, proving on Day One of 2025 that no one celebrates quite like Ocean Bay Park.

We recently said goodbye to several beloved members of our community. John Lindsey, a proud and loyal member of the Ocean Bay Park Volunteer Fire Department, served for 45 years. Dennis J. Curry, with his brother Peter, became a fixture in OBP over many years, serving up pizza, seafood, and memories. Ted Caccia was known for his spirit and tennis game; a celebration of his life is planned for summer 2025. Julia Arcadipane, married for 58 years to William, shared a life between New York City and their home on Superior Street. Patty Loesch, a longtime resident, gave generously to the OBPA board and the Fire Department Auxiliary.

Over the winter, the Ocean Bay Preservation Association (OBPA) completed several projects aimed at improving the community. The wooden walkway to the ferry was replaced and looks fantastic. New trash cans, dune signage, and benches have also been added. Most striking is the newly widened beach, thanks to the Army Corps of Engineers. I have never seen it so expansive. To help protect the shoreline, the OBP Community Fund Inc., a new 501(c)(3), approved a $10,000 contribution toward vital dune plantings.

Exciting changes are happening on the food scene. Two new restaurants, sharing a single building, are set to open this spring. On the Way Café, owned by Anna Vigliotti and Kris Schillinger, will offer breakfast treats to start the day. Samui, created by Angie Ma and Michelle Solomon, will serve authentic Thai food, bubble teas, and sake-based cocktails. Both restaurants look amazing, with their outdoor spaces also getting a refresh. 

The Ocean Bay Park Fire Department held its Annual Chief Michael Horton Spaghetti Dinner on May 11, a tradition started by Chief Mike Horton, who, sadly, passed away last year. Diners enjoyed a great meal and the energy of OBPs young volunteers, in a night that honored Mikes lasting legacy. From talking with business owners, town leaders, social groups, and neighbors island-wide, I can say this season will be one to remember here in Ocean Bay Park. I cant wait to see you at the party. Happy Memorial Day!